3 interfaces, What is your favorite?

[Weider]

What is your favorite? It's all made by me in 3d, but I make some photoshop work for #2 and #3.

#1 (http://agora.ulaval.ca/~dalav123/test/untitled.html)
#2 (http://agora.ulaval.ca/~dalav123/test/untitled01.html)
#3 (http://agora.ulaval.ca/~dalav123/test/untitled02.html)


For the moment, they are only sketches, so I make an whole image with the site.

[Crismo]

I definitely preferred number 2.
Number 1 is to sharp and seams just more intrusive.
While number 3 is a bit to boring.

[Karl Freeman]

i like the 1st one it looks the most real. definatly the 1st one

Karl

[smoothhabitat]

2nd one.

[Ordinathorreur]

1, just tone down the red border around the signs a little....

[Timmee_3Styler]

404 right nnow :(

[ralphot]

#1! IMHO, it's more "alive".

[Weider]

Timmee_3Styler , sorry it's fixed now...

so


#1=3
#2=2
#3=0

ON another board,m I got

#1=2
#2=1
#3=1

thanks for your replied, I hope some others will reply to have a cool survey :p

Maybe a cool idea will be to have a choice like at mecano's website. you can chose between the 3 render before enter to the site.

[flashlight]

One more vote for #1

[tweaknee]

a vote for #2

[smoothhabitat]

i'm voting twice for #2.

[Weider]

smoothhabitat: hahaha!! you've still voted!! :P or depending if your girlfriend voted too

for the moment, the total vote it:

#1=6
#2=4
#3=1

[Esquared]

chalk another up for #2....definitely the most interesting atmoshpere.

[Ruben]

#2

I definitely preferred number 2.
Number 1 is to sharp and seams just more intrusive.
While number 3 is a bit to boring.

That's what I thought as well...maybe you should start a new thread here with a poll in it...so you wouldn't have to count anymore ;)

:p - Ruben